Still of Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara in ‘Hot Pursuit.’ Photo courtesy of Warner Bros.

A Los Angeles judge ruled that Sofia Vergara’s former fiance can have a copies of her driver’s license and records of her past and present employment information in their ongoing legal battle over her frozen embryos, but he denied a request that the actress admit to alleged past statements on abortion.

Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rafael Ongkeko said that despite the objections of Vergara’s attorney, Fred Silberberg, the driver’s license information could be useful to Nick Loeb and his attorneys to confirm the actress’ identity and the former couple’s relationship.

“I erred on the side of, `OK, why not?,”’ the judge said.

The 48-year-old former “Modern Family” star sued Loeb, 45, in February 2016, seeking a court order declaring that any attempts by him to bring the pre-embryos to term is a breach of their original contract.

Loeb has sued Vergara in Louisiana for control of the two embryos, which were created at the ART Reproductive Center in Beverly Hills in 2013 when they were a couple and were trying to have a child via surrogate.

Silberberg maintained the driver’s license information was not relevant because the case involved an alleged breach of contract and not a personal injury. He said Vergara works through a personal service corporation, also known as a “loan-out” company, and that there were privacy concerns about releasing her employment information.

But the judge stated in his written ruling that there was no evidence Loeb’s request represented a “serious” invasion of Vergara’s privacy.

Loeb’s lawyer, Jalesia McQueen, said her inquiries were fair and that her client has turned over 50,000 pages of personal information to Vergara.

“I don’t think asking for her employment is going to break them,” McQueen told the judge.

Ongkeko said he was not going to grant Loeb’s request that Vergara admit she allegedly told him during their relationship that she opposed elective abortion or that she punched him in the face, kicked him and threw a phone at his head while they were together.

“The court finds that these requests ask highly personal, sensitive information that have very little to no relevance to the issues in this case, i.e, whether a breach occurred,” Ongkeko wrote.

The judge denied motions by both sides for financial sanctions against each other, saying none of the lawyers did anything to warrant such punishment.

“Each side has passionate feelings about the areas of dispute,” the judge said.

Silberberg argued that Vergara deserved sanctions from Loeb because McQueen has not made a serious effort to meet and confer about discovery disputes and that she could have gotten even more information had she done so. He said the defense requests for information were meant to “harass” Vergara.

But McQueen denied she refused to try and resolve the issues out of court.

“If there’s been any refusal, it’s him,” McQueen said of Silberberg.

Vergara, who has an adult son, married actor Joe Manganiello in November 2015.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.