A 54-year-old Cathedral City man is asking for an adjustment in a jury’s overall verdict because the panel awarded him no past pain and suffering damages for a trip and fall he suffered at Dodger Stadium in 2022.

In court papers filed Monday with Judge Karine Mkrtchyan, plaintiff Jamie Merchain’s attorneys state that he should either be granted a new trial on the issue of past non-economic damages, or be granted an additional $250,000 from the Dodgers. The amount is what the jury granted Merchain for his future emotional distress. The overall damages amount awarded in the jury’s Oct. 26 verdict was $495,740.

“When a jury finds that a defendant’s negligence caused an injury that required surgery, a verdict awarding nothing for pain and suffering is inadequate as a matter of law,” Merchain’s attorneys write in their pleadings.

In their previous court papers, Dodger attorneys denied Merchain’s allegations and said Merchain “so carelessly, recklessly, unlawfully and negligently conducted and maintained himself so as to totally cause and/or contribute in some degree to the alleged incident and the damages and injuries.”

According to Merchain’s attorneys’ pleadings, their client fell over uplifted asphalt at Dodger Stadium on April 20, 2022. He was walking from the parking lot toward the center field gate and the uplift on which he tripped may have been caused by a tree root, the plaintiff’s attorneys further state in their court papers.

When Merchain tried to stand, he had severe pain in his shoulder and neck and went back down, the plaintiff’s lawyers further state in their court papers.

The Dodgers’ security staff called for medical help and he was taken to first aid, then came the drive home to Riverside County in which Merchain was in pain the whole time, the plaintiff’s lawyers further state in their court papers.

Merchain went to a hospital emergency room the next week and after his release he stayed home-bound for the first week, unable to raise his left arm and at the beginning stage of suffering from headaches, the plaintiff’s attorneys contend in their pleadings.

Merchain’s left shoulder was treated with injections and his neck required a two-level cervical disc replacement about a year after the fall, according to the plaintiff’s attorneys’ court papers, which further state that Merchain described his recovery as “painful. It was a whole week of just can’t move pretty much. Can’t eat nothing really.”

Merchain still has intermittent neck pain and feels a “shock” in neck when he turns quickly, plus he still has headaches and he no longer hikes, swims or takes his grandson fishing, the plaintiff’s lawyers further state in their court papers.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *