jury room
Jury Room - Photo courtesy of Alexander Oganezov on Shutterstock

After hearing roughly two weeks of testimony, jurors began deliberating Wednesday in the retrial of accused Palisades Fire arsonist Jonathan Rinderknecht, whom federal prosecutors say set a small brush fire around midnight on New Year’s Eve 2025 that smoldered for a week before Santa Ana winds re-ignited the flames that grew into the deadly conflagration.

Earlier this year, a separate jury deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquitting Rinderknecht, 30, of charges of destruction of property by means of fire, arson affecting property used in interstate commerce, and timber set afire. Following that mistrial, prosecutors secured a superseding indictment with only two charges — destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce.

In the new indictment, the first charge refers only to Rinderknecht’s alleged setting of the Lachman Fire on New Year’s Eve, rather than the Lachman and Palisades fires.

During the trial in downtown Los Angeles, Assistant U.S. Attorney Matt O’Brien argued that Rinderknecht, a former Uber driver, was consumed by anger, loneliness and a thirst for revenge, prompting him to use a grill lighter to ignite hilltop vegetation around midnight on Dec. 31, 2024, at the remote, deserted area adjacent to the Pacific Palisades’ Summit neighborhood. That fire was dubbed the Lachman Fire, named for a street near the Skull Rock Trailhead

Prosecutors said firefighters initially thought they had extinguished the Lachman Fire, but instead it smoldered underground for six days in the root system of brushes and trees before bursting into view as the deadly Palisades Fire on Jan. 7, 2025, bolstered by strong Santa Ana winds.

But defense attorney Steven Haney argued there was no direct evidence proving that his client set the New Year’s Eve fire, saying the prosecution’s case lacked any witnesses to the alleged crime and consisted only of circumstantial allegations.

“There’s no direct physical evidence supporting their arson claims,” Haney told jurors at the onset of the trial.

Haney suggested the first fire was likely caused by errant New Year’s Eve fireworks. The defense attorney said Rinderknecht was on the trail near the Hidden Buddha clearing where the Lachman Fire was thought to have started, but he did nothing more than call 911 to report it.

O’Brien conceded nobody saw Rinderknecht start the fire, but he said witnesses, video surveillance, cell phone data and analysis of fire dynamics and patterns at the scene show he intentionally set the Lachman Fire then lied about it to investigators during an eight-hour interview.

The Palisades Fire was the most destructive blaze in Los Angeles history, killing 12 people, burning 23,448 acres, costing billions in damage and insurance claims, and ruining much of the exclusive Pacific Palisades community, destroying about 6,500 structures across the Palisades and Malibu.

Rinderknecht remains in federal custody while on trial because three separate judges found that he is a danger to the community. The findings were based on evidence showing, among other things, that he hid a firearm in a child’s teddy bear and threatened to burn his sister’s house down in Florida.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *