One Year Ago Today (October 5, 2021)…A 41-year-old convicted felon knew what he was doing when he killed a woman in Thermal, a prosecutor argued, but his attorney asserted he was mentally infirm and urged an Indio jury to find him insane at the time of the crime.

Raul Alcantar Sanchez Jr. was convicted last week of murder for killing 34-year-old Carolina Vargas in November 2012, and the trial immediately moved into the sanity phase at the Larson Justice Center.

“Someone can understand that something is illegal but still believe they are morally doing the right thing,” Sanchez’s attorney, Kimberly Allee, said in her closing statement for the sanity phase.

Allee said her client could not comprehend the gravity of his actions because of his psychoses, pointing out he was given to hallucinations and hearing voices, obliterating his ability to realize repercussions or the morality of his decisions.

Sanchez stabbed Vargas more than 100 times, including 50 times in the face and neck, during a frenzied assault.

Allee cast doubt on the credibility of a doctor who testified that her client was not psychotic during the attack, referring instead to medical reports that did find him mentally incompetent.

Deputy District Attorney Anne-Marie Lofthouse told jurors that Sanchez was looking for a way out of responsibility for the slaying, and that he knew what he was doing the entire time.

In her trial brief, the prosecutor quoted the defendant threatening the victim, telling her, “I’m gonna open you and eat your insides.”

Lofthouse said he threatened the victim multiple times, showing he had a clear intent to kill Vargas and “affirmed that intent with each stab wound.”

The prosecutor noted that Sanchez spoke to his father days after the killing and apologized for perpetrating it, reflecting normal reasoning in comprehension of the difference between right and wrong.

According to Lofthouse, there was planning and sophistication revealed in the defendant’s decision-making, including the fact that he waited for his father to be away before following through with his threats against Vargas, who was the elder man’s love interest.

Sanchez resented her presence and behavior toward him in the close confines of the mobile home the three occupied in the 85000 block of Middleton Street, according to trial testimony.

The attack happened on Nov. 21, 2012, while the elder Sanchez was out of the house.

The defendant cornered Vargas inside the doublewide and used a screwdriver and knife to inflict the dozens of deadly puncture wounds.

Sheriff’s deputies found Vargas’ body inside the residence soon afterward and arrested Sanchez near the scene, wearing pants covered in her blood, according to the prosecution.

“This is a disordered thought process. This is psychosis,” Allee said.

She told jurors that her client had a history of psychosis, a fact borne out by his commitment to a state mental hospital, where he underwent clinical treatment that culminated in findings that his mental fitness had been restored, at which point he was placed in the Benoit Detention Center in Indio to await criminal proceedings, according to court papers.

Sanchez’s prior felony convictions include burglary, vandalism and grand theft.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *