A legal challenge backed by Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s commutation of sentences for 548 death-row inmates was filed over the weekend, the nonprofit leading the effort announced Monday.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation said it filed the lawsuit on behalf of elected district attorneys, law enforcement leaders, victims’ rights organizations and victims’ relatives, seeking to block Newsom’s blanket commutations of death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The suit alleges Newsom failed to provide legally required notice to district attorneys and denied victims and their families an opportunity to be notified and heard. It also contends the governor exceeded his clemency authority by issuing the commutations without meaningful individualized review.
“This lawsuit is about protecting the constitutional rights of victims, defending the rule of law, and ensuring that no Governor is above the law,” CJLF President and CEO Anne Marie Schubert said in a statement.
“The Governor’s clemency power does not authorize mass commutations that disregard constitutional safeguards, legally required procedures, or victims’ rights,” Schubert said. “By predetermining the outcome for every inmate on death row, the Governor has abandoned his responsibility to exercise meaningful discretion.”
In response to a City News Service request for comment, the governor’s office referred to Newsom’s letter announcing the commutations, in which he acknowledged the anguish the decision could cause victims’ relatives.
“This decision is among the most difficult of my career, not because I doubt its necessity for our state but because I know its announcement may surface excruciating memories for victims’ families,” Newsom wrote. “I deeply respect the views of those who will strongly disagree with my decision, including some families of victims who have suffered the worst possible loss.”
Newsom wrote that voters had retained the death penalty but that the commutations neither repeal it nor prevent prosecutors, juries and courts from seeking, imposing or upholding death sentences in future cases.
“But the constitution also gave every governor clemency authority, and that power exists for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice,” Newsom wrote. “For me, this is that moment.”
Hochman backed the challenge last week, saying victims’ families had been sidelined by the governor’s action.
“We stand firmly with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in challenging this arbitrary commutation that sidelines victims’ families and disregards the will of California voters, juries and judges,” Hochman said.
The district attorney said prosecutors make a promise to victims’ families that the facts and law will be allowed to play out in court, and that they will seek the death penalty when justified by the facts and law.
According to Hochman’s office, 162 of the condemned inmates whose sentences were commuted are from Los Angeles County, including “Southside Slayer” Chester Turner and “Hollywood Ripper” Michael Gargiulo. The office said about 382 of the 548 cases involve people convicted of more than one felony.
Greg Totten, CEO of the California District Attorneys Association, said prosecutors were deprived of an opportunity to provide information and ensure victims and their families were heard.
“No Governor should be permitted to circumvent the very safeguards designed to ensure that justice is served,” Totten said.
The foundation also cited the results of statewide ballot measures, noting that voters rejected Proposition 34 in 2012 and Proposition 62 in 2016, which would have repealed the death penalty. Voters approved Proposition 66 in 2016, aimed at speeding death-penalty appeals.
Newsom announced the commutations last week, writing that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values and diminishes the legal system.
“I know we cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them justice and human decency,” Newsom wrote in an open letter to California residents.
California has not executed anyone since Jan. 17, 2006. Newsom, a longtime opponent of capital punishment, imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019.
The governor said some cases involving people with multiple convictions will require review by the California Supreme Court.
