Outgoing Gov. Gavin Newsom Thursday announced his commutation of death sentences for all 548 people on California’s Death Row, who will now serve life in prison without the possibility of parole, eliciting a denunciation from Riverside County District Attorney Mike Hestrin.
“I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, undermines the foundations of our legal system and diminishes each of us,” Newsom said.
“I know we cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them justice and human decency.”
California has not conducted an execution since Jan. 17, 2006. Newsom, a long-time opponent of the death penalty, issued an executive order in 2019 placing a moratorium on executions in the state.
“He commuted the sentences without notifying the district attorneys whose offices prosecuted these cases and secured the convictions and sentences,” Hestrin said in response to the announcement Thursday. “Alarmingly, he did this without individualized input from each family of the victims, whose lives were taken by these convicted murderers.”
Prior to his election to top prosecutor in the county in 2014, Hestrin handled multiple capital punishment cases, and prevailed in all of them. The exact number of convicts from the county in line for commutations wasn’t immediately available.
“Rather than undertake a careful, case-specific review of the evidence, legal proceedings and circumstances of each case, the governor once again chose to inject politics into California’s criminal justice system,” Hestrin said. “This sweeping action, taken without meaningful consultation with prosecutors or victims’ families, raises serious questions about whose interests the governor is truly representing.”
Newsom acknowledged the individuals who received death sentences “caused indescribable suffering to victims, their families, communities and our state as a whole.”
“The harm they inflicted persists across generations,” he added. “Many Californians feel that those who commit brutal crimes deserve to die. But as governor, I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them. … We can now let these offenders die in obscurity while we forever remember and honor their victims.”
Newsom, who will step down on Jan. 4 due to term limits, handing over the reins to Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, pointed out that his action doesn’t abolish the death penalty, only commutes the sentences of those who are currently on Death Row.
“The power to repeal the death penalty rests with the Legislature and voters,” he said. “The discretion to seek, impose and uphold death sentences in individual cases remains, as ever, in the hands of prosecutors, juries and courts. But the constitution also gave every governor clemency authority, and that power exists for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice.”
Hestrin characterized Newsom’s act as an affront, saying the state should have “leaders who put politics and personal ambition aside and pursue truth, accountability and justice with courage, integrity and transparency.”
“Instead, they have been presented with a decision that demonstrates a profound disregard for the victims, their families and the prosecutors who dedicated themselves to seeking justice on their behalf,” the district attorney said.
According to Newsom, his “clemency grants” are not unconditional for those persons who were convicted of felonious offenses two or more times.
“My decision to commute all death sentences, therefore, compels the involvement of the chief justice and associate justices in a unique inter-branch constitutional process,” the governor said “While I am confident this act of categorical clemency is consistent with California law, I acknowledge that my decision to exercise my constitutional clemency authority requires the justices to participate in a weighty decision they did not choose to take up and with which they may personally disagree.”
It was unclear how many clemency reviews may take place.
Leaders of the American Civil Liberties Union were quick to praise Newsom’s decision.
“These commutations reflect what justice demands: an end to a racist, error-prone and inhumane punishment that has burdened California for far too long,” ACLU Executive Director Anthony Romero said in a statement. “By taking this step, Gov. Newsom has affirmed that the death penalty has no place in California and he showed real courage by confronting racialized injustice head-on.”
ACLU SoCal Executive Director Chandra Bhatnagar said that “from its inception, California has imposed the death penalty in a racially discriminatory manner, creating a two-tiered system of justice. With this historic act of (collective) clemency, the state can turn the page — rejecting a broken, biased system and embracing a more just and equitable future for all.”
