Attorneys for a lighting technician on the film “Rust’ who is suing Alec Baldwin and other defendants, alleging he suffered emotional distress from the actor’s accidental fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins, have filed new court papers disputing defense contentions that the plaintiff’s damages were minor.
In court papers previously filed with Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Karine Mkrtchyan in advance of a Dec. 4 hearing, attorneys for first assistant director David Halls and Rust Movie Productions LLC say the technician, Serge Svetnoy, is overstating his damages. On Nov. 13, Baldwin and his company, El Dorado Pictures Inc., joined the motion in seeking to have the case transferred to a limited jurisdiction court.
But in new court papers filed Thursday, Svetnoy’s attorneys say it is not only late in the game to file such a motion, but the technician’s emotional distress damages are well above the $35,000 threshold to remain out of a limited jurisdiction court. The lawyers say a psychiatrist who evaluated Svetnoy concluded that the crew member suffered a “persistent, clinically significant trauma- and stressor-related condition” from being exposed to the gun’s discharge and that the condition persists five years later.
Halls’ attorneys themselves have filed hundreds of written questions, inspection demands and admissions requests on Svetnoy, the sheer quantity of which is well beyond what would have been authorized in a limited civil case, according to Svetnoy’s attorneys’ court papers.
“Further still, an eleventh-hour reclassification after the trial date has been set and continued numerous times would be fundamentally at odds with the cost-savings and delay reduction purposes of the applicable statute,” according to the plaintiff’s lawyers’ pleadings.
In their court papers, Halls’ attorneys state that Svetnoy, among other things, did not seek medical treatment, has never consulted a health care provider for any injury he attributes to the event, has no work restriction and expressly disclaims any past lost earnings. The Baldwin-El Dorado lawyers concurred in their court papers.
“Plaintiff’s total damages cannot exceed the $35,000 threshold, regardless of whether plaintiff claims entitlement to those damages from Halls or from the Baldwin defendants,” the actor’s attorneys state. “Any relief provided to Halls should therefore be afforded to the Baldwin defendants as well.”
Trial is scheduled for March 8. Svetnoy claimed in his original suit filed in November 2021 that the shooting on the film’s set “was caused by the negligent acts and omissions” of the multiple defendants. In a subsequent amended complaint, Svetnoy added causes of action for assault and intentional infliction of emotional distress against Baldwin only.
Svetnoy was among the first “Rust” crew members to publicly speak out about the 2021 shooting that killed the 42-year-old Hutchins while Baldwin was helping to prepare camera angles on the film’s set near Santa Fe. The weapon, which was supposed to contain only blank rounds, discharged a lead bullet that struck Hutchins in the chest then lodged in the shoulder of director Joel Souza, now 53.
In July 2024, a New Mexico judge dismissed the criminal case against Baldwin in mid-trial on grounds that the prosecution had suppressed evidence.
