An Orange County Superior Court judge has partially approved Orange County’s temporary restraining order request curtailing some picketing by a Teamsters local, but the ruling may become moot as the union’s strike nears an end.
Judge Scott Steiner issued a ruling Sunday granting the county’s TRO request in part.
Steiner sided with county officials who claimed that picketers were blockading waste truck traffic to the county’s three landfills. Teamsters Local 952 officials have denied the county’s claims.
“The county has shown a likelihood of prevailing on its claim that the repeated physical obstruction constitutes a public nuisance,” Steiner wrote. “Peaceful labor activity remains protected, but unlawful blocking of access is not protected (by law).”
Steiner did not weigh in on whether the strikers contributed to a fire at a landfill in Santa Ana.
The judge said he “makes no finding that union misconduct caused the Santa Ana fire or the entire decline in landfill tonnage.”
The union can continue picketing and attempt to cajole truckers to not cross a picket line, Steiner said.
“The order removes only the ability to physically prevent passage” of traffic into the landfills, Steiner said.
The judge also noted but did not yet weigh in on the union’s claim that the county violated labor law with refusals to continue negotiations.
A hearing is scheduled for Nov. 30 in the North Justice Center in Fullerton on a request for a preliminary injunction.
“Hopefully it’s a moot point,” Orange County Board Vice Chair Katrina Foley said as she noted the Teamsters local overwhelmingly ratified a new contract offer.
“The board has to vote on Dec. 1 to ratify the members’ ratification,” Foley said. “I think we’re in a position where everyone wants to move forward. We have to learn the lessons from this. There needs to be a better bargaining with our bargaining group and better communication.”
Foley said it troubled her that the county did not have a range of salary levels for its workers.
“We started negotiating with all these groups in January, February and March with zero range built into the budget,” Foley said.
“This has not been a good chapter in county history,” she said. “People got hurt, businesses suffered and critical employees were not available to do critical work during significant storm systems. We have to do better — all of us. People are really struggling right now. The cost of living in terms of impact on working families is significant.”
Foley said one of her goals for the upcoming years is to “really begin to develop a proactive economic development plan for the county.”
The increase in representation in Sacramento of Democratic lawmakers coupled with the Orange County congressional delegation may free up more dollars for the county, which struggles as it receives the least amount of state funding back, Foley said.
“We can’t afford to not be reimbursed for mandates” from the state, Foley said. “That contributes to why we’re in this fiscal situation and not being able to keep up with the cost of living.”
