A former Uber driver was convicted of a pair of federal charges Friday for setting a New Year’s Eve 2025 fire that smoldered for seven days before Santa Ana winds re-ignited the flames that became the Palisades Fire that destroyed much of the Pacific Palisades community and killed 12 people.
Jurors deliberated for about two and a half days before convicting Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, of destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce.
Sentencing was scheduled for March 17, when Rinderknecht faces up to 40 years in prison.
Earlier this year, a separate jury deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquitting Rinderknecht of charges of destruction of property by means of fire, arson affecting property used in interstate commerce, and timber set afire.
Following that mistrial, prosecutors secured a superseding indictment with only two charges. In the new indictment, the first charge referred only to Rinderknecht’s setting of the Lachman Fire on New Year’s Eve, rather than the Lachman and Palisades fires.
During the trial in downtown Los Angeles, Assistant U.S. Attorney Matt O’Brien argued that Rinderknecht was consumed by anger, loneliness and a thirst for revenge, prompting him to use a grill lighter to ignite hilltop vegetation around midnight on Dec. 31, 2024, at the remote, deserted area adjacent to the Pacific Palisades’ Summit neighborhood. That fire was dubbed the Lachman Fire, named for a street near the Skull Rock Trailhead.
Prosecutors said firefighters initially thought they had extinguished the Lachman Fire, but instead it smoldered underground for six days in the root system of brushes and trees before bursting into view as the deadly Palisades Fire on Jan. 7, 2025, bolstered by strong Santa Ana winds.
But defense attorney Steven Haney argued there was no direct evidence proving that his client set the New Year’s Eve fire, saying the prosecution’s case lacked any witnesses to the alleged crime and consisted only of circumstantial allegations.
“There’s no direct physical evidence supporting their arson claims,” Haney told jurors at the onset of the trial.
Haney suggested the first fire was likely caused by errant New Year’s Eve fireworks. The defense attorney said Rinderknecht was on the trail near the Hidden Buddha clearing where the Lachman Fire was thought to have started, but he did nothing more than call 911 to report it.
O’Brien conceded nobody saw Rinderknecht start the fire, but he said witnesses, video surveillance, cell phone data and analysis of fire dynamics and patterns at the scene show he intentionally set the Lachman Fire then lied about it to investigators during an eight-hour interview.
The Palisades Fire was the most destructive blaze in Los Angeles history, killing 12 people, burning 23,448 acres, costing billions in damage and insurance claims, and ruining much of the exclusive Pacific Palisades community, destroying about 6,500 structures across the Palisades and Malibu.
One of the jurors, who identified himself only as Cameron, told reporters outside the courthouse that he originally believed Rinderknecht was not guilty, but he said as the jury discussed the evidence of the course of their deliberations he now believes he is guilty.
“The strongest evidence was the defendant’s own testimony stating that he was up on the hill, didn’t smell a fire, didn’t see fireworks,” Cameron, 30, said. “It was a clear, calm night. You know, no one else was on that hill that day, or that day or night, and (he) happened to be smoking, and because he happened to be smoking, he had a lighter.
“Therefore, everything kind of started to point towards one conclusion, especially if there was no one else on that hill, no fireworks, no electronic or no lighting strikes, like nothing else underground that was found through the tests and investigations.”
He said he could not say whether Rinderknecht had the intention of burning down Pacific Palisades.
“What I will say is that his intent was to start a fire. What that fire did after … only he will know and only God will know. And so the result of his fire is what ultimately led to January 7,” he said.
Rinderknecht’s father, Joel, told NBC4 after the trial that he still believes his son is innocent, and he called the verdict a miscarriage of justice. He told the station is was an impossible task to fight against the “steamroller” of the federal government seeking a conviction.
Bill Essayli, first assistant U.S. attorney in Los Angeles, called the verdict a “tremendous testament of the hard work that went into this case.”
“All of us remember the devastating images early last year of people fleeing their homes, the fire destroying structures,” Essayli said. “Twelve people lost their lives, 6,800 homes burned, $25 billion in damages. And the question at the time was who is responsible. And now we have the answer to that question.
“… I really, really want to thank the attorneys, the trial lawyers in my office who tried this case not once but twice,” he said. “A lot of people wanted us to just give up after the first trial, but we were confident in the facts.”
Kenny Cooper, special agent in charge of the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives in Los Angeles, credited investigators who worked on the case to determine the origin of the blaze.
“Using our state-of-the-art, world-renowned fire research lab, we conducted over 500 scientific experiments on some of the causes, potential causes of this fire,” he said. “Our national response team was brought in with subject matter experts, with certified fire investigators, our chemists, our engineers, our canine accelerant teams that came in. Hundreds and thousands of acres these investigators combed through to find the smallest pieces of evidence. We had over 17,000 items of evidence that we processed, over 1.5 million digital forensic data points to go through.
“… I can’t be more proud of the men and women in all the specialties that we brought to this investigation,” he said.
Haney told the Los Angeles Times he plans to appeal the verdict.
“We are disappointed in the verdict, but respect the jury process,” he said. “After a lengthy deliberation, they clearly gave this case a great deal of consideration.”
Rinderknecht has remained in federal custody while on trial because three separate judges found that he is a danger to the community. The findings were based on evidence showing, among other things, that he hid a firearm in a child’s teddy bear and threatened to burn his sister’s house down in Florida.
“While today’s verdict is an important step, it’s not closure,” Los Angeles City Councilwoman Traci Park, whose district includes the Palisades, told reporters outside the courthouse. “It’s not full accountability. There is still a lot more for us to do.”
She noted that a lot of progress has been made in the Palisades to recover from the fire, but much remains. She said the end of the trial “takes sort of one distraction off of a very crowded playing field of moving pieces.”
“You know, over the last 18 months, we have done an historic effort just with the debris removal, moving more debris out of the Pacific Palisades burn area than out of Ground Zero at 9/11,” she said. “We have in the last 22 months returned many of our schools and our local beloved businesses, and we see more and more families returning home. If you’ve been to the Palisades lately, you see the construction and the incredible momentum, and I see that too.
“… And for so many other victims of this fire, of the intentional conduct and choices that were made by one person that has caused so much harm, this struggle is far from over,” she said.
Mayor Karen Bass added in a statement, “Nearly two years ago, the Palisades Fire devastated our city, taking innocent lives, destroying thousands of homes, and changing so many lives and Los Angeles forever. No verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain families have endured. So many are still struggling to rebuild. For those still displaced, the devastation remains a daily reality.
“Los Angeles will always stand with Pacific Palisades,” she said.
