Transcripts of the grand jury proceedings that led to the filing of a murder charge against a former Coachella sheriff’s deputy accused of killing a man he viewed as a romantic rival will remain sealed, a judge ruled Wednesday, though certain portions could be made public at a later time.
Oscar Rodriguez, 36, is charged in the Jan. 27, 2014, shooting death of Luis Carlos Morin outside his family’s Coachella home. Morin’s ex- girlfriend, Diana Perez, 39, is charged with being an accessory.
The District Attorney’s Office initially cleared Rodriguez in the shooting, but a lawsuit filed against the county by Morin’s family led to a reopening of the investigation. The suit detailed the lawman’s alleged dating relationship with Perez, who had two children with the victim.
Rodriguez allegedly went to the home under the guise of arresting Morin for outstanding warrants, then grappled with him and shot him once in the upper body. Family members claim he hid in the bushes, then ambushed Morin after he and family members returned from a birthday celebration.
The former deputy’s attorney, Mark W. Fredrick, argued that releasing the transcripts to the public would be unduly prejudicial to his client.
After Rodriguez was indicted in December, transcripts of the grand jury proceedings were ordered sealed for 10 days. Fredrick moved to have the order extended for a month, but subsequently sought to have the transcripts sealed through the end of the trial.
At a hearing Wednesday morning, Riverside County Superior Court Judge Harold W. Hopp agreed to keep the transcripts sealed, though he said testimony from certain witnesses may be allowed for release at some point prior to the beginning of the trial. Attorneys will reconvene in the coming weeks to discuss which witnesses’ testimony will remain under seal and what testimony might be released.
Fredrick argued in court papers that news coverage of the indictment has been “extremely unfavorable to Mr. Rodriguez, convicting him of murder before a trial.” He said that in contrast, Morin has been “painted through news outlets as a loving and peaceful man.”
Fredrick also criticized District Attorney Mike Hestrin, saying the county’s top prosecutor “convicted Mr. Rodriguez in the press” and described him as a “rogue deputy,” “taking care of personal things.”
Rodriguez, who remains out of custody, faces life imprisonment if convicted, while Perez would face up to three years.
–City News Service
>> Want to read more stories like this? Get our Free Daily Newsletters Here!Follow us: