Angel Stadium
Angel Stadium. Photo by John Schreiber.

A former defense attorney for the ex-Los Angeles Angels public relations executive convicted of providing a deadly dose of fentanyl to star pitcher Tyler Skaggs Monday disputed his ex-client’s assertion in court papers that he was bullied into going to trial instead of accepting a plea deal.

Eric Kay, who is seeking an evidentiary hearing in a motion for a new trial, argued in part that he was pushed into going to trial after he had decided to accept a plea deal that would have meant far less time in prison than the 22-year term handed down when he lost.

Skaggs was found dead in a hotel room while on a road trip with the team July 1, 2019. Kay was convicted in federal court in Texas of providing the fatal dose of fentanyl to Skaggs and was sentenced to 22 years in prison.

In his latest appeal, Kay claims he was initially offered a plea deal with a sentence between 84 months and 120 months. Then he was offered a deal between 60 months and 120 months on Oct. 7, 2021, he said.

But his former defense attorney disputed the claim.

“He was never offered that little and nobody pressured him,” Kay’s trial attorney Mike Molfetta said.

The defense attorney said Kay had a deadline to make a decision, which he had been mulling for weeks.

“He came into the office the day the decision had to be made,” Molfetta said. “We went back and forth. When it came down to 5 minutes before a decision has to be made he said, `I can’t believe you sprung this on me at the last minute.”’

Molfetta added, “He literally knew about it for weeks. He had been made the same offer. This would have been the third time. He had discussed the offer for about a year. We discussed it a lot. And then to turn around and say he was pressured into it.”

Molfetta pointed out that Kay’s sentencing judge indicated he would have handed down a lesser sentence but then he saw the transcript of a phone call between the defendant and his mother that he concluded showed he had no remorse over his role in Skaggs’ death.

Kay said his mother audio-recorded part of the Oct. 12, 2021, meeting with Molfetta and that he was prepared to admit he was guilty of drug trafficking.

“Molfetta refused to acknowledge that fact, and took a hectoring, even bullying approach,” Kay contended in the motion.

Kay said Molfetta threatened to withdraw as his attorney and would not represent him if he pleaded guilty.

“He also threatened in that event to go public to the media about the case, an eventuality that was distressing to Mr. Kay, who wanted to avoid further publicity about the case for the sake of his family,” according to Kay’s motion.

Molfetta told City News Service he had known Kay for years and was a friend of the family.

Kay’s motion alleges ineffective assistance of counsel for not doing more to interview the government’s witnesses on the topic of evidence showing Skaggs wouldn’t have died if not for the fentanyl. He faulted Molfetta for an “erroneously optimistic view of Mr. Kay’s chances of prevailing” on the question of what caused Skaggs’ death.

Kay argued in the motion that Molfetta wrongly relied on the autopsy, which concluded Skaggs died of mixing alcohol with fentanyl and oxycodone and the government could not prove the fentanyl alone was what killed the pitcher.

Kay’s motion also argues that the government’s case “relied extensively on evidence obtained from Mr Skaggs’ phone,” and added, “But that evidence is unreliable. Records show that after Mr. Skaggs died and while in the custody of law enforcement, the phone continued to receive text messages, calls, and other content consistent with network connection — heightening the possibility, vehemently denied by the government at trial, that content was deleted or altered from the phone.”

Kay argued that “raw data” from Skaggs’ phone closest to the time of his death from the Southlake Police Department is no longer available.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *