A 23-year-old schizophrenic and chronic marijuana user who claimed insanity for fatally shooting a young man and woman as they watched a film at a Corona movie theater behaved in ways that proved he could differentiate between right and wrong, a prosecutor said Tuesday, while the defendant’s attorney said his client’s actions point to a “person who is literally insane.”
“These were the acts of a young man who is mentally deranged,” defense attorney Charles Kenyon said in his closing argument in the sanity bench trial of Joseph Jimenez. “Joseph is a person with cognitive impairment. His ability to reason and process things has been compromised.”
Jimenez fatally shot Anthony Barajas, 19, and Rylee Goodrich, 18, both of Corona, in 2021 at the Regal Edwards Theater.
Jimenez admitted the killings, but according to the defense, he was insane at the time of the crime. The burden of proof in the two-week trial at the Riverside Hall of Justice, where only Riverside County Superior Court Judge Timothy Hollenhorst has heard evidence, has been on the defense.
“Joseph cannot discern right and wrong,” Kenyon said. “He doesn’t recognize things in real time. There are things highlighted in his brain that aren’t there. He’s hearing ghosts.”
The attorney acknowledged Jimenez has appeared normal throughout the trial because “he’s been medicated for 28 months, and he’s in a controlled environment,” a deep contrast to his life leading up to the killings.
Kenyon described how his client suffered following the loss of his mother a year prior to the deadly attack and was plagued by voices commanding him to engage in violence and even take his father’s life before the elder Jimenez could kill him and his sisters.
He assaulted his dad on two separate occasions, and in the last attack, on Dec. 29, 2020, he attempted to choke him to death, according to the defense. Jimenez had invented a past that turned his father into a gangster, bent on perpetrating harm on his son and daughters.
“He suffered paranoia, thinking he was being watched and chased by people in Hondas and Subarus,” Kenyon said. “This is a person who is literally insane. He thinks he is going to die. All of his delusions were 100% schizophrenia.”
The week prior to the theater shooting, his father went to Mexico, leaving Jimenez alone in a mobile home, “without real world distractions, alone in his head, hopped up on energy drinks because he can’t sleep and voices in his head telling him to do things.”
The attorney said the “persecutory delusions,” which several psychologists found valid, “caused him to kill.”
“He could not understand the moral wrongness of his act,” Kenyon said. “He did not realize until afterward the true horrors he brought.”
Deputy District Attorney Kevin Beecham countered the defense on virtually every point, emphasizing that Jimenez was not bereft of help, being admitted to hospitals for mental health treatment multiple times over the 11 months prior to the killings.
“The discharge orders were always the same — take your medication and don’t do drugs,” Beecham said, “But he does the exact opposite.”
According to the prosecutor, Jimenez failed to show up for appointments with doctors, didn’t get his psychotropic medications refilled and regularly used marijuana and “chugged” alcohol, capturing much of the recreational substance abuse on his cell phone camera and sharing the images.
Beecham said while the defense sought to paint Jimenez as a sympathetic character, “he’s not credible, and he has a tendency to exaggerate facts and a history of placating practitioners.”
“You can take all of his statements and throw them in the trash,” the prosecutor told the judge.
Beecham pointed to videos of him smoking cannabis and conversing normally with friends as evidence Jimenez wasn’t out of control. Further proof surfaced in his procurement of a 9mm home-assembled “ghost gun” a month prior to the theater attack.
“He paid $1,000 for it. He has to get a ghost gun because he knows he’s not going to pass a background check,” Beecham said.
On the night of July 26, 2021, Jimenez joined his best friend, Julian Velasquez, and two other high school buddies to see “The Forever Purge,” a horror film about societal collapse. Only the four friends and the two victims were in the theater.
Velasquez testified Jimenez was behaving erratically, murmuring to himself and staring down his pals.
Beecham recounted that although Jimenez gave the impression of lacking lucidity, he took time to “hit on a girl” before going into the theater and was alert enough to know where to go unassisted. Within a few minutes of the movie starting, Jimenez left and retrieved a backpack from his car, then returned and sat back down. A few rows ahead of him sat Barajas and Goodrich.
Velasquez said he asked Jimenez what was in the backpack, and Jimenez replied, “a strap,” or a handgun. Velasquez said he and the other two friends became fearful and left, as did Jimenez, but the defendant decided to go back into the theater.
“Leaving the theater is a huge, significant fact,” Beecham said, recalling how Jimenez later told detectives he decided to return to the cinema because he didn’t want to miss the last 20 minutes of the film. “He’s not in imminent fear.”
Jimenez said “voices” told him to kill the victims, each of whom he shot in the head, then “sprinted to his car” and fled to his residence, Beecham said.
“That shows consciousness of guilt,” he said.
Jimenez is charged with two counts of first-degree murder, along with special circumstance allegations of lying in wait and taking multiple lives.
If Hollenhorst rules insanity, the defendant will be committed to a mental institution for an undetermined period. If he’s found sane, he’ll be imprisoned for life.
He’s being held without bail at the Smith Correctional Facility in Banning.